Peace Like A River


It was a wide river, mistakable for a lake or even an ocean unless you'd been wading and knew its current. Somehow I'd crossed it... Now I saw the stream regrouped below, flowing on through what might've been vineyards, pastures, orhards... It flowed between and alongside the rivers of people; from here it was no more than a silver wire winding toward the city. - Leif Enger, Peace Like A River

Sunday, September 25, 2005

Creating the Iraqi Army

In this post, Bill Roggio mentioned Operation Sayaid, which is now getting underway. Part of this plan calls for the Iraqi 7th Army Division to provide permanent security in the region.

This is the only way the US will be able to extricate itself from Iraq with hopes of leaving behind a nation able to stand on its own, if the Iraqi forces are able to perform security functions by themselves.

This Iraqi 7th Division trained under the II Marine Expeditionary Force.

This photo shows some of the Division in training. This photo is from CentCom, and the caption read:

Iraqi army recruits assigned to 3rd Battalion, 1st Brigade, 7th Division, participate in a practical application exercise on entering and exiting a convoy during hostile fire at the Eastern Fallujah Iraqi Camp, located on Camp Fallujah, on July 26, 2005.


I emailed the II M.E.F. to ask about how this 7th Division was formed, and if the makeup of the division might have an impact on its security mission, given it will be operating largely in the Anbar region. This area is largely Sunni, and in general I wonder if significant numbers of Shiite troops operating in Sunni areas might pose difficulties. Iraq will see success only if they can get past these sectarian differences, at this enough to see the Iraqi Army as a national army.

A Major with the Public Affairs Office of Multi-National Force - West emailed me back. This was his reply:

Thank you for your interest in Iraqi Security Forces.

The Iraqi Army, as you may know, is a national (and secular) army, designed much like our own services.

Soldiers are recruited and assigned to units and deployed to areas that they are needed. Recruiting continues and the ISF is striving to ensure that the population of Iraq is well and equally represented in their armed forces.

As I mentioned earlier, all the units are secular and are designed to reflect the make up of the population: Shiite, Sunni and Kurd. Therefore there will be more Shiite than Sunnis and Kurds simply because the country is predominantly Shiite. The 7th Div will be located and operating in Al Anbar province and is a mixed unit.

After speaking with our liaison to the ISF, we are seeing that the units in our area of operation are not only performing, but they are having success. Just as the Marines send forces anywhere and we adjust to work with the local population and gain their trust, the Iraqi Army has done and continues to focus on doing that.

For instance, a commander of one of the units is a Sunni, he will assume command of units that are a widely mixed. Conversely, another commander is a Kurd who has an XO that is Sunni and a chief of staff is a Shiite.

Finally, as a commander speaking to my new Marines in the past, I've explained our Marine Corps, (and now the Iraqi military) like this:

Units are like orchestras. You need many of people with all kinds of backgrounds. Some are violins, some are tubas and we even have some triangles and bells, but the resulting sound is one that can move people and inspire greatness. In our case, our concert hall is anywhere we deploy and the ISF is expected to be employed in the same manner.

Historically, you can even look at the civil war or many other wars where units came from different geographic locations with different backgrounds in the US and were able to mix and achieve success. This model is intended to help establish national unity as well.

From my own experience here now and from 2 years ago, it is common to see people from all backgrounds living in the same neighborhoods. One house will fly a Sunni flag and their neighbor will fly a Shiite flag. Despite what may be reported, I find Iraq to be a religiously tolerant nation.

Hope this helps explain your questions. Thanks for your kind wishes as well!


The Iraqi Army has seen encouraging success lately, for instance in Tal Afar. It is encouragin if mixed units can work together and perform the tasks necessary to rebuild Iraq, and provide security for their fellow countrymen.

4 Comments:

  • At Sun Sep 25, 11:52:00 AM, johngrif said…

    More good news. Thanks for sharing it with us.

    There is another point that may be worth considering. I'm not sure who made it, but the point could be from Michael Yon's on site look at Iraq.

    It is said,

    An Iraqi founds it possible to be many things--1--(not sure of this order) a member of a large extended family, 2--a member of his tribe,3-- a member of his town,4-- a Sunni/Kurk/Shiite/other, and 5--fiercely devoted to his country.

    He see no conflict. He is all those things.

    This wholeness may be a strength; perhaps it is a hindrance in some ways. Your report does augur well.

    In contrast, division marks America.

    In the secularized West often it is common for us to be hyphenated citizens (Euro/Afro--urban/rural--rich/poor--etc.).

    Our identity is always a compromised one.

     
  • At Sun Sep 25, 09:11:00 PM, Jeff said…

    That might be Yon. My correspondent in Iraq has said similar things. It is one of those aspects that make Iraq such a very different place. Makes it harder for us to understand.

     
  • At Mon Sep 26, 01:20:00 PM, Anonymous said…

    JGrif comment is quite accurate to an very large extent.
    (another cogent and related topic is the ongoing saga in afghanistan. similar in that you have disparate ethnic groups that have, despite odds and history, tended to unite under some type of banner(s) as a quasination)
    A Modern Iraqis identity is due to various influences of the twentieth century not the least of which is nationalism. However, for anyone of whatever ethnic background, this ancient region of Messopotamia has created within its inhabitants a unique identity. The borders of Europe changed with the wind unlike this particular region. For many reasons due to geography, any one who ruled this area pretty much got the whole package of what is now iraq. Coming out of the more easily defending syrian and turkish high plateau, The forbidding saudi desert and persian mountains create this large flat area with the only water around.
    The modern arab nationalist movement and the power of the secular baathists also influenced modern Iraqi identity.
    Much of all this applies to more or less all Iraqis since Kurds are also spread out south of "kurdistan" in the north, However, the kurds have their own unique story and so for them, they are often Kurds first before(or Iraqi-Kurds when it fits the situation)they are 'Iraqi'.
    A good example of events related to national unity was/is the Olympics in which the soccer team was hailed far and wide by all. Sadly, there are vast divides in other areas.
    All of that, however, is not to say that Iraq does not have a history of tolerance. Very much not the case.
    (This gets complicated:all throughout this(or any)regions history there are certainly exceptions to the rule)
    Except under flareups of internecine conflict of one type or the other, Iraqis generally are/were/do pride themselves on their intermingled tolerant relations. It is no surprise to see a Kurd marry a Jew, sunni to shia, christian to a muslim(although that of course is much rarer since like anything in this region groups tend to insularity and cousin type marraige is common/expected/proper etc)
    Ask any of them, in general, they will say, we all get along. And that is by and large true.
    Problems and violence stem from larger issues(like Baathist revolution, Saddam coups/purges/uprisings etc)
    but religious tensions are mostly benign. It is lately alquado/wahhabi wackos and like minded violent ideologues fueling sunni/shia tension and violence.(islam has a long history of those types of periodic flareups in many countries. but most of all that was settled soon after mohammid died and the main sunni shia split arose.
    all that is no surprise. protestant vs catholic did too)
    So...
    the US military has, in part, tried to grasp these realities and mindful of other examples all over the world, tries to make an effort to be diverse in its composition of the armed forces.
    Much is in flux and transition. Until some truly/widely homegrown(not seen as cia stooge like allawi and chalabi) accepted leaders and politicians and military figures arise(years from now it will happen)
    loyality is hard to what is hard to generate and pin down.
    So, most fall back on other identities.
    Confusing at times I know.
    All that being mentioned, some trends overall have become clear. The largely shia units from the southern iraq and of course, Kurdish type units have proven amenable to working with US units. (the local police force issue is a completely different huge complex issue)
    (under the saddam baathists, you could be sunni, shia, kurd, christian, whatever, didnt matter so much as long as you and tribe/family proved loyal)
    However, within a unit there certainly are sunni and shia and by and large no problems exist. kurds tend not to exist in some units. others do. just depends once again. This varies widely depending on unit and location.
    But working with US units, iraqis in a way, at least right now, have to abide by our guidelines to be diverse, fair, plural etc.
    I have seen issues(just like anywhere, really, whether it be church, prison or high school like say in the usa) where someone or a click has an issue because so and so is known to hold allegiance to this ideology/clan/mullah/ayatollah etc etc or someone is from this region, or this group is country hicks or from a backwards tribe or this a snooty well to do tribe/family. whatever, we dont tend to get involved in any of that.
    Overall, its good the US is trying to be inclusive and create a nationalistic force more loyal to country than tribe(a basic tenet of nationlism. see the classic "Lawrence of Arabia" where he meets Omar shariffs character at the well..."unless you unite you will always be subjugated(or words to that effect))
    How will this all play out?
    Whoa, we have got to get to the referendum and dec election.
    My guess, it will get voted down by the necessary amounts needed and this whole process starts over and the timetable is pushed back a year.
    I dont know how likely that is but thats where the bookies seem to be headed and when money is on the line, they tend to be more correct than pundits and politicians.
    It might be just as well. The sunni groups are NOT pleased with the current document and it might help to just start over with proportionate representation(they only got their seats on the drafting council by US insistence after last elections boycott left the sunnis out of the loop)but that would require they VOTE this time, which, thankfully, most indicate they want to do this time for the Dec election.
    What a mess.
    A juicy steak dinner for some young MBA state department intern to stew over in the green zone!
    Make me king?
    I wouldnt be the first to say the trend would/should be to let nature take its course and create a loose federal state and/or autonomous zones and then equitably share the oil wealth.
    (Lets call a spade a spade, thats what the (publicaly unstated) US policy was to do in settling the Yugoslavia fiasco and the subsequent Serbia/Kosovo split. Do you have a better solution? That didnt involve more war? Or would you rather ignore it all for years and years like the rest of Europe did? That was shameful)
    That road has lots of pitfalls and detractors but what other options are workable?
    Let a dictator take over again and thats the only way to keep these idiots together. An iron fist of brutality and misery.
    No one wants that. But that seems to be what it takes, doesnt it?
    Otherwise,these folk dont seem to get along well in close association.

     
  • At Mon Sep 26, 01:21:00 PM, Anonymous said…

    ps
    jgrif. i agree. TRoosevelt said it best, "there is no room for a hyphenated american.

     

Post a Comment

<< Home